All trades · Pricing

Why your quotes keep losing money (3 pricing mistakes)

Here's the frustrating version of running a trade shop: the phone rings, the quotes go out, the jobs get done, the crew is exhausted — and at the end of the month there's nothing left. The work isn't the problem. The pricing is, and usually in one of these three places.

Mistake 1: Pricing from your wage instead of your cost

The most common pricing formula in the trades is: "I pay my tech $35 an hour, so if I charge $95 an hour, I'm making $60." Run the real numbers and the $60 evaporates:

  • Burden: payroll taxes, workers' comp, and insurance add roughly 25–40% to that wage. $35 becomes $44–$49 before anything else.
  • Unbillable time: if only 55% of paid hours get billed, each billed hour must carry the cost of the other 45%. Your effective labor cost per billed hour is now around $80–$89.
  • The truck: payment, fuel, maintenance, and insurance for one service truck commonly run $1,200–$1,800 a month — call it $10–$14 per billable hour.

Add phones, software, and marketing and your "$60 of profit" is a small loss, repeated on every job. The fix isn't charging wildly more — it's pricing from a loaded rate that starts with what an hour actually costs you. An hour of homework, once, fixes every quote after it.

Mistake 2: Treating overhead as "whatever's left"

Overhead is real money spent on real things: insurance premiums, the shop lease, office help, licensing, tools that walk away, the accountant. Shops that don't assign overhead a percentage of every job aren't avoiding the cost — they're paying it out of the profit line and calling the result "a slow month."

Do it properly once: total last year's overhead, divide by last year's revenue, and you have your overhead percentage. For most small shops it lands between 10% and 25%. Put that percentage into every price as a line item, the same way you count fittings. If a job doesn't cover its share of overhead, the other jobs are subsidizing it — and there is no line in your price for "subsidy."

Mistake 3: Discounting to win the job

This is the quietest and most expensive mistake, because it feels like customer service. A customer hesitates, you knock off 10% to close it, everyone shakes hands. But a discount doesn't come out of "the price" — it comes entirely out of profit, because your costs didn't drop 10%.

On a job priced at a 20% margin, a 10% discount takes profit from 20% of the price down to about 11% of the original price — you gave up nearly half your profit to feel 10% nicer. Do that on one job in three and you've donated a meaningful slice of your year. And it compounds: the discounted price becomes the anchor for that customer's next call and their neighbor's referral.

Alternatives that protect the number: reduce scope, not price ("we can skip the water-softener loop this visit"); offer a good/better/best choice so the customer discounts themselves into a smaller job; or hold the price and add something cheap-to-you and valuable-to-them, like a one-year workmanship warranty extension. The price was built from your costs — treat it that way.

The pattern underneath all three

Every one of these mistakes is the same mistake: pricing from a feeling instead of from your costs. The feeling is understandable — you're standing in a customer's kitchen, not an accounting office. That's exactly why the math has to be done in advance, in the price book, so the number you say out loud was decided by your spreadsheet and not by the moment.

See what your quotes should be

The free calculator builds a price from labor, materials, overhead, and margin — and shows you, in dollars, what a 10% discount does to that job's profit.

Try the free calculator